Steve Kilbey solo album tournament (closed) in The Feast Forum

RSS
Email

0 Points

Steve Kilbey solo album tournament (closed)

Author	Comment
chrome3D	Steve Kilbey solo album tournament (closed)	Lead	[-]
Posts: 5335 (02/17/2008 22:48) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Tags : tournament Remove this ad the winner of Steve Kilbey solo tournament is THE SLOW CRACK! Unlike some previous games this game is very simple. For you it has only one rule: - Two albums have a match. Vote for your winner. Order of the albums has been randomized. One round takes about 24 hours. If the result is a tie, then the result will be counted by popularity in the internet, using rateyourmusic.com, last.fm and the number of posts in hotelwomb.com MATCH 1: Acoustic & Intimate vs. The Slow Crack Last Edited By: chrome3D 02/25/2008 22:47. Edited 4 times.
chrome3D	match 1	#1	[-]
Posts: 5335 (02/17/2008 22:49) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	The Slow Crack I really love A&I but I have to go with TSC. The first 4 songs are sooo good.
ynnpar		#2	[-]
Columbus Posts: 706 (02/17/2008 23:54) Glow Worm Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Acoustic & Intimate.
Altres		#3	[-]
Posts: 866 (02/18/2008 00:22) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	The Slow Crack. Wonderful. Brian
fandorin		#4	[-]
Posts: 5900 (02/18/2008 03:22) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Slow Crack. Incredible EP. I have 4 versions. Original 8 song EP, LP with 3 songs plus, without "like a ghost", LP with the whole Transaction EP. And the CD. You don't know how much I love this album. > then the result will be counted by popularity in the internet, using rateyourmusic.com, > last.fm and the number of posts in hotelwomb.com will you tell us the statistical weight of each factors? e.g. multiplication by a factor depending on the number of site users on RYM/LastFM etc.? ...because strange is what we need The Fandorin Foto Files
chrome3D		#5	[-]
Posts: 5335 (02/18/2008 03:51) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	fandorin wrote: will you tell us the statistical weight of each factors? e.g. multiplication by a factor depending on the number of site users on RYM/LastFM etc.? 33,33 % weight for each tree different factors, not taken in to account the number of users etc. If there is 3 different factors, then result can not possibly be a tie...it has to be either 3-0 or 2-1...unless one of the factors is a tie...and then my head will explode... example : Album 1: RYM: 3,50, 1 point Album 2: RYM: 3, 25 Album 1: Most popular song in last.fm: 5, 1 point Album 2: Most popular song in last.fm: 11 Album 1: number of HW posts in one thread: 22 Album 2: number of HW posts in one thread: 35, 1 point Then that means album 1 wins. This is getting way too nerdy, but that´s the whole fun!
Dugster		#6	[-]
Faith Healer Columbus Posts: 981 (02/18/2008 08:50) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Hey a simple game! Count me back in. The Slow Crack is a great album and a clear winner. Never really appreciated the A&I album - like the vid with the filmed intros by SK though. Anyway The Slow Crack to win! The right hand side of your chart looks trickier though...
timetunnel		#7	[-]
Snowfaller Posts: 447 (02/18/2008 13:32) Glow Worm Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Slow Crack, of course
Joffaa		#8	[-]
Posts: 871 (02/18/2008 16:11) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I love A&I but the slow crack it is
camel	for me	#9	[-]
Posts: 4817 (02/18/2008 21:12) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	NARCOSIS+more across the endless sky we are deployed
chrome3D		#10	[-]
Posts: 5335 (02/18/2008 22:11) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Remove this ad Thanks, camel, but that was a bit early. Wait until match 3 to do that again!
chrome3D	Steve Kilbey solo album tournament, match 2	#11	[-]
Posts: 5335 (02/18/2008 22:12) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	That was quite clear result. Win for The Slow Crack. Match 2: Earthed vs. Freaky Conclusions Vote for your winner.
chrome3D	match 2	#12	[-]
Posts: 5335 (02/18/2008 22:16) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Freaky Conclusions I end up skipping most of Earthed usually. There is some good stuff, but the opener is so much better as "Favourite Pack". Again, SheMeWe and Mechanism are good songs, that I don´t get tired listenining to. I know it´s a compilation of sorts but it´s the voice I want more than just instrumentals. This will be interesting. Unlike match 1, I´m not sure how this will end.
ynnpar		#13	[-]
Columbus Posts: 706 (02/18/2008 22:29) Glow Worm Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Earthed takes this round for me. There are some classical little bits of pretension on here. And the accompanying book of poetry is pretty much what got me started thinking that I wanted to make literature and the study of literature my career. What a, erm, great decision that was. Definitely big bucks there! Yeah, thanks for that SK. Really though, "Old Jupiter is writing the dawn poems, it's a brand new day and..." Incredible. FC is just a gathering together of odd bits from here and there and doesn't do much for me.
camel		#14	[-]
Posts: 4817 (02/18/2008 22:47) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	d'oh... should have paid closer attention across the endless sky we are deployed
camel	playing by the rules now	#15	[-]
Posts: 4817 (02/18/2008 22:51) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	EARTHED ...the record is hit-or-miss, but the good outweighs the bad. Meanwhile the accompanying book is a bonafide CLASSIC! Ah, the adventures of Neuman, etc. F.C. has its share of jewels, but Earthed takes this round. across the endless sky we are deployed
fandorin		#16	[-]
Posts: 5900 (02/18/2008 23:04) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I love both equally....but WEIRD OLD WORLD and FREAKY CONCLUSIONS are 2 songs i absolutely cannot live without....so 1st FC Freaky Conclusions wins against Arsenal Earthed ...because strange is what we need The Fandorin Foto Files
Wayne		#17	[-]
Posts: 1157 (02/19/2008 02:26) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Earthed It's a sentimental vote for me
Dugster		#18	[-]
Faith Healer Columbus Posts: 981 (02/19/2008 05:07) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Freaky Conclusions definately. Earthed is ok but never really sticks with me enough. FC is great. The full An Arrangement is fantastic!
Joffaa		#19	[-]
Posts: 871 (02/19/2008 16:35) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I absolutely love freaky conclusions and gets my vote. A great collection of songs that I am so glad saw the light of day.
Heyday2day		#20	[-]
Glow Worm Posts: 293 (02/19/2008 19:49) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Remove this ad Would love to pitch in here and cast a vote for Freaky Conclusions but it would be a tainted vote for I have never listened to Earthed. I have read about it and my interest has been piqued but I would need to have the book that goes with it. Is it out of print now? Are the liner notes with Earthed extensive enough to give a real feel for what the poetry is all about? Don't count my vote here, I don't really have a valid opinion until the big Dabble vs. Unearthed showdown comes. Love the idea and the education/opinions though.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Steve Kilbey solo album tournament (closed)

Steve Kilbey solo album tournament (closed)