Survivor game: Masterplan in The Feast Forum

RSS
Email

0 Points

Survivor game: Masterplan

Author	Comment
chrome3D	Survivor game: Masterplan	Lead	[-]
Posts: 5335 (10/17/2007 21:42) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Tags : survivor Remove this ad I thought it would be clear to open a new topic for the discussion how to end the game and not to hide it in another thread. Heres my suggestion: - All rest of the albums, BW2B, ULTC and EMS will be in voting format. - I want to do the rarities partly again. A poll for rarities of 80s, 90s and 00s. - Bastard Universe will be included in 90s rarities and Jammed in 00s rarities. No songs will be left out. - All winners of games will be divided by decades and there will be voting for each of the three decades. - In the ultimate final the best song ever will be selected from the 3 candidates Here are the nominees so far: 80s: Of Skins And Heart : BEL-AIR Blurred Crusade : AN INTERLUDE Sing-Songs EP : A DIFFERENT MAN Seance : DISAPPEAR? Remote Luxury EP : A MONTH OF SUNDAYS Persia EP : SHADOW CABINET Heyday : MYRRH Starfish : HOTEL WOMB Rarities 80s: WARM SPELL Best runner-up: ANTENNA 90s Gold Afternoon Fix: LAUGHING A quick smoke at Spots : THE FEAST Priest=Aura: AURA Sometime Anywhere: AUTHORITY Somewhere Else EP: THE MYTHS YOU MADE Magician Among the Spirits + some: WELCOME The Refo:mation: THE MOON AND THE SEA Hologram of Baal: ANAESTHESIA A Box of Birds: HIROSHIMA MON AMOUR Rarities 90s: FOG Best runner-up: METROPOLIS 00s After Everything Now This: AFTER EVERYTHING Parallel Universe Mixture: ESPIONAGE Parallel Universe Remixture: RADIANT 1934 Forget Yourself: JUNE Beside Yourself: CRASH/RIDE El Momento Descuidado: ALL I KNOW Back with Two Beasts: SNOWFALLER Uninvited like the clouds: DAY 5 El Momento Siguiente: IT´S NO REASON (acoustic) Rarities 00s: UNDO Best runner-up: TELEPATH _______________ Survivor of 80s: MYRRH Survivor of 90s: - AURA Survivor of 00s: DAY 5 Ultimate Survivor: AURA Last Edited By: chrome3D 12/23/2007 21:42. Edited 4 times.
Wayne	Re: Survivor game: Masterplan	#1	[-]
Posts: 1157 (10/18/2007 02:53) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Why not? It's all fun and games. Actually, after looking at all those final songs, it seems to me that the 80's are stacked with the biggest amount of 'BIGGER,BETTER, MORE KNOWN' songs (and thats not bad). That's my POV of course. And of course a lot of my favourite songs missed out...... but, what are ya gunna do?......... It will be interesting. Cheers
Boriah	Re: Survivor game: Masterplan	#2	[-]
Space Saviour Posts: 1391 (10/18/2007 03:28) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Honestly, looking at the winners the final poll will be soooo easy. At least for me. "Theres only two ways of making a song: your way or the wrong way" (Trevor Rabin) www.myspace.com/thebylawsofthecrib www.myspace.com/triptych31
Wayne	Re: Survivor game: Masterplan	#3	[-]
Posts: 1157 (10/18/2007 03:47) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	BEL AIR to win.............
Boriah	Re: Survivor game: Masterplan	#4	[-]
Space Saviour Posts: 1391 (10/18/2007 05:54) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Chrommo, you forgot one POLL: "Best THE CHURCH album" "Theres only two ways of making a song: your way or the wrong way" (Trevor Rabin) www.myspace.com/thebylawsofthecrib www.myspace.com/triptych31
camel	Re: Survivor game: Masterplan	#5	[-]
Posts: 4817 (10/18/2007 08:53) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	EMS is such a great disc. Collectively, our list of winners would make a great compilation. across the endless sky we are deployed
chrome3D	Re: Survivor game: Masterplan	#6	[-]
Posts: 5335 (10/18/2007 21:45) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Marcelo wrote: Chrome - interesting suggestion. I'd prefer to do the voting by different definitions of the eras, rather than 80s, 90s, and 00s. But I guess we'd have a hard time agreeing on how to define the eras. My vote would be as follows: ERA 1: 1981-86 ERA 2: 1988-92 ERA 3: 1994-99 ERA 4: 2001-07 My main concern with splitting the 80s from the 90s is that we'd be splitting Starfish from GAF, which clearly belong together. This especially applies to the b-sides from each album found on AQSAS. I see Texas Moon and The Feast, for example, as part of the same era, and not split by a decade divider. Overall, Starfish belongs with GAF and P=A much more than with Heyday or the earliest albums. _____________________ I thought about this. What I like about dividing it to three parts for each decade is that every part gets almost same amount of songs. Dividing them with those eras, would mean there would be different amount of songs for each era. Aqsas was voted as one album and The Feast is a 90s song, so its okay for it to be there in the 90s.
Altres	Re: Survivor game: Masterplan	#7	[-]
Faith Healer Space Saviour Posts: 1857 (10/20/2007 07:47) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I agree, only I'd have Heyday in the Starfish to P=A group. Brian
ynnpar	Re: Survivor game: Masterplan	#8	[-]
Columbus Posts: 706 (10/21/2007 23:57) Glow Worm Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	What about also including all the songs that finished second in each of the polls - wild card spots, of sorts? It's a lot more songs, but there could be double eliminations in the early rounds. This might make for some amusing results. Thoughts?
fandorin	Re: Survivor game: Masterplan	#9	[-]
Posts: 5900 (10/22/2007 00:01) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I'd definitely include Heyday, seems to start their second period. ...because strange is what we need Fandorinfotos
chrome3D	Re: Survivor game: Masterplan	#10	[-]
Posts: 5335 (10/22/2007 00:01) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Remove this ad I thought about it and yeah, why not? Sort of like a "dark horse". I only thought about having one for each decade. A poll for that too.
disciple	for me	#11	[-]
Posts: 987 (10/22/2007 07:51) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	There are three periods for the commercial albums: 1981-1985 - "Memories In Future Tense" OSAH BC S RL 1986-1995 - "Heyday" H S GAF PA SA 1996-2007 -"After Everything, Now This" MATS HOB AENT FY ULTC And there is also: 1981-2007 - "You're Still Beautiful" AQSAS BOB PU EMD BWTB EMS
Hanani	Re: for me	#12	[-]
Space Saviour Posts: 1252 (11/01/2007 23:33) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I am particularly akin to disciple's idea It's profound, actually. It's also all good to me.
fandorin	Re: for me	#13	[-]
Posts: 5900 (11/02/2007 00:47) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	SA and MATS must go to the same period. period. ...because strange is what we need Fandorinfotos
chrome3D	Re: for me	#14	[-]
Posts: 5335 (11/02/2007 01:29) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I dont think there will be any clear result which album should go to which era. Im sorry but I will follow my initial plan (as originally suggested by Dugster) and go with the decades.
fandorin	Album Survivor	#15	[-]
Posts: 5900 (11/09/2007 05:56) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Will there be: - Survivor of all albums - Album Cover survivor ?
avocadro	Re: Album Survivor	#16	[-]
Columbus Posts: 977 (11/09/2007 11:13) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	And regarding albums... given Church history which would be the actual albums (and their covers) to vote out? Even if we just follow Fipster's list of albums (removing EPs and Collections) some albums have alternate covers (and I'm not talking about Box of Birds)... Everybody has opinions: I have them, you have them. And we are all told from the moment we open our eyes, that everyone is entitled to his or her opinion. Well, thats horsepuckey, of course. We are not entitled to our opinions; we are entitled to our informed opinions. Without research, without background, without understanding, its nothing. Harlan Ellison Be a scientist, save the world Rick Smalley (1943-2005)
chrome3D	Re: Album Survivor	#17	[-]
Posts: 5335 (11/12/2007 05:36) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Will there be: - Survivor of all albums - Album Cover survivor ? OF COURSE there will be! I might even have to invent new ways to play those, as especially cover art survivor is a bit tricky.
fandorin	Church of Poo	#18	[-]
Posts: 5900 (11/12/2007 07:02) Faith Healer Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	There also should be a Worst Song Survivor. All the songs that went first will be gathered, and the worst one must survive, i.e. the best one must be voted out first, until we have a finale of atrocity!
ynnpar	Re: Church of Poo	#19	[-]
Columbus Posts: 706 (11/12/2007 07:04) Glow Worm Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Oooooooh, now that is a great idea!
avocadro	Re: Church of Poo	#20	[-]
Columbus Posts: 977 (11/12/2007 11:32) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Remove this ad Yes!!! A worst song "survivor", vote to rescue the songs you don't want to remain in the "worst song heap"! Great idea. Everybody has opinions: I have them, you have them. And we are all told from the moment we open our eyes, that everyone is entitled to his or her opinion. Well, thats horsepuckey, of course. We are not entitled to our opinions; we are entitled to our informed opinions. Without research, without background, without understanding, its nothing. Harlan Ellison Be a scientist, save the world Rick Smalley (1943-2005)

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Survivor game: Masterplan

Survivor game: Masterplan